For All Mankind

Michael Bettencourt | Scene4 Magazine

Michael Bettencourt

The Marvelous María Beatriz and I have stumbled upon the Apple TV series For All Mankind, a counterfactual history of the race for space. The series begins with the 1969 moon landing, with the familiar (well, “familiar” to a certain generation) grainy images of the lander on the moon and the slow descent of an astronaut to the surface. Except that in this telling of the tale, it is a Soviet cosmonaut who first touches down, not an American, and from that historical twist springs the arc of the series.

The season we just finished, Season 4, released in 2023 (there is a Season 5, with Season 6, the last season of the series, scheduled for 2027), has a pretty deft take on some of the issues currently roiling our world, though it is set in 2003: capitalist exploitation, worker rebellion, colonialism, divisive politics, resource extraction. It gives some of the soap opera-ish elements an edge and bite.

Here’s the setup. On Mars exists an outpost called Jamestown, a colony jointly administered by the United States and the Soviet Union (yes, it is still the Soviet Union). Al Gore is president, and the political situation in the Soviet Union has had a shake-up because of a conservative coup d'état. The cosmonauts in Jamestown are in disagreement about the politics, which raises the political tension throughout the community for everyone.

There is a third partner in this venture: Helios, run by Dev Ayesa. His ambition is to establish Mars as a cognate of Earth. He made his money earlier in the series by mining helium-3 on the moon, which has created a clean, non-polluting fuel that completely demolished the fossil fuel industries. (It’s also thrown all the workers in those industries out of job, which creates its own cluster of tensions within American society – and ironies, with politicians finding themselves arguing for the return of the climate-destroying fossil fuels in order to preserve jobs).

The administration and running of Jamestown, then, falls to three groups: the Americans, who are in command of the base, the Soviets, and Helios through its worker bees who literally live in the steerage section of the Jamestown hab units, isolated, exploited, demoralized. (There is a contingent of North Koreans as well. Long story about how they got there, but they also have a dog in the hunt about commanding the resources of Mars.)

Then, from out of the blue (well, the inky black of deep space) comes 2003LC, an asteroid moving into the inner solar system that is rich in iridium that may be worth $20 trillion when fully mined. The United States, the Soviet Union and Helios are salivating to grab the goodies, but the workers stage a strike that threatens to scuttle the overlords’ plans to lasso the asteroid and drag it into Earth orbit so that the iridium can be fully extracted without the exorbitant costs of mining it at Mars and transporting it to Earth.

In steps Helios who, in cahoots with some disaffected Americans, Soviets, and North Koreans, manages to steal the asteroid to keep it within the orbit of Mars and thus keep the Jamestown enterprise going by making it essential. (The truth was that when the asteroid reached Earth, the Mars tents would be folded up and brought home, and those who now consider Mars more their home than Earth were not going to let that happen.)

The United States and the Soviet Union have no choice but to move their mining ambitions back to Mars, which causes an expansion of Jamestown to hold thousands of people (some of them migrants who stowaway on the supply ships that furnish the colony – they are known as “craters,” people who have hidden away in the crates.) The last episode of the season shows Dev looking up at the asteroid as it circles the planet, and then the camera flying up to the asteroid to show outposts and mining facilities studding the rock, indicating that humans are now beavering away at pulling it apart.

What the season shows, as the show itself has always shown, is that the strong aspiration to achieve an existential purity by flying to the stars – the focused mission, the selflessness of the team, pushing the bounds of knowledge, the devotion to a purpose larger than one’s self – cannot be severed from the impure gnarl of human greed, need, deceit, desire, blindness, sadness.

Mars is seen as a new Eden (the title of an episode in Season 3); many scenes in many episodes focus on the awesome and shut-my-mouth beauty of the planet’s austere and perilous landscape (also true when the space travelers were only on the moon). For a moment, these people looking out to the horizon are literally out of their minds, existing in a timeless state that feels glorious in its suspension of the usual demons roiling around inside.

Then, of course, the ordinary muck of human life seeps back in, and people are at each other’s throats once again, pursuing their narrow interests, taking risks without adequate information, driven by regrets and guilts and betrayals.

There are not too many productions being broadcast these days that show workers uniting to break the stranglehold of the
owners, rebellion and dissent against the overlords, the perils of colonizing to the colonizers as well as the glories of engineering and the rarefied beauty of the pursuit of science. (Time and again time, the engineers, shunting their feelings of the moment to the side, depend on facts and imagination to solve the problems blocking their way – a true belief in fact, logic, sharing, revelation. Refreshing.)

That being said, For All Mankind is not an adept Marxian analysis of class conflict and the false consciousness of capitalist exploitation. It’s riddled with soap opera banalities and sometimes moves way too slow dramatically. But it is clever in how the writers, directors, and producers deal with these larger questions of power and survival, authenticity and expediency, better angels and betrayals. Definitely worth a watch. 

inView

June 2026

 

Share This Page

View readers’ comments in Letters to the Editor

Michael Bettencourt is an essayist and a playwright,
He is a Senior Writer and columnist for Scene4.
Continued thanks to his “prime mate"
and wife, María-Beatriz.
For more of his columns, articles, and media,
check the Archives.

©2026 Michael Bettencourt
©2026 Publication Scene4 Magazine

 

 

THEATRE THOUGHTS
and
OCCASIONAL MUSINGS

and creates
VIDEOS

YOUR SUPPORT

If you enjoy this issue please consider lending a hand. Scene4 is a global magazine featuring reviews, commentary, criticism, essays, fiction, photography, paintings, graphics and poetry. Founded as a monthly in 2000, with over 300 issues during the past 26 years of publication and an accessible, comprehensive archive of over 18,000 pages (a unique array of articles as comtemporary as when they were first published). In these disruptive times, we need your help and support to weather the
storm. Please make a contribution of any size by going to our support page here and gather the appreciation of our authors, artists and editors.

  Sections This Issue · inFocus · inView · inSight · Perspectives · Special Issues
  Columns  Adler · Alenier · Alpaugh · Bettencourt · Gallas · Jones · Luce · Marcott · Walsh 
  Information Masthead · Your Support · Submissions · Archives · What’s New  ·  Books
  Connections          Contact Us · Comments · Subscribe · Letters

 | Search Archives | Share This Page |

Scene4 (ISSN 1932-3603), published monthly by Scene4 Magazine
of Arts and Culture. Copyright © 2000-2026 Aviar-Dka Ltd – Aviar Media Llc.

June 2026