The Steiny Road to Operadom | Karren LaLonde Alenier | www.scene4.com

Sharpening the Impulse of Collaborative Composing: A Look Behind the Scenes

Karren Alenier

On June 22, 2025, the Alliance for New Music-Theatre held a recital for the 15 participants of a two-week workshop entitled Composer-Librettist Studio that involved writing words and music for one or more singers to perform. At the invitation of poet Nathalie Anderson, one of the five librettists of this project, the Steiny Road Poet, along with her opera partner Janet Peachey, attended the recital held at the University of the District of Columbia in Washington, DC. The group of 15 included five composers, five librettists, and five singers. With each assignment, a new pairing of composer and librettist occurred.

Anderson, who is an accomplished librettist having premiered several operas with composer Thomas Whitman, agreed to a July 9th, 2025, interview to provide insight into this demanding workshop. Written in Anderson’s words,  the detailed descriptions of the five projects clearly reveal that each participant needed a certain level of experience. This was not a workshop for
beginners.

The New Music-Theatre Assignments

1.  Regular Rhythms and Operative Words.  This assignment asked us to create formally regular rhythmic lines, aiming at iambic pentameter.  We were asked to make note of the stresses, noticing especially when they departed from the iambic norm; and we were asked to provide and identify an "operative" word -- crucially significant -- in each line.  The composer's task was then to work with and around the formal rhythm to convey natural speech patterns, and to emphasize the operatives to convey emotion.  We were given NO guidelines on topics or situations.  Each team worked with one singer.

According to Anderson, no one did this assignment exactly as stated. She herself usually avoids writing in traditional forms and instead aims at producing words and phrases that create rhythmic patterns. What she learned from this exercise was that complicated vocabulary can be hard for singers to pronounce. This was particularly so for their assigned singer Ruslan Bondar, a Ukrainian baritone new to singing solos in English. One interesting aspect of working with this singer was he had an ability to sing falsetto. This added extra texture and emotional load to Anderson’s story of “Petty Professor Curenton.”

2.  Plot Beats.  This assignment drew on exercises using story-boarding to visualize the "plot" of "Jack and Jill."  We were asked to imagine a situation involving two people.  One person is in a particular place.  A second person comes in.  Things progress.  We were encouraged to create a plot with perhaps five "beats," marking stages in the story.  The composer's task was to mark those plot developments with appropriate musical
changes.  Each team worked with two singers
.

Anderson’s story for this assignment entitled “Blood Tells” dealt with two vampires who did not immediately recognize that the other was also a vampire. The musical elements included blues and Eastern European waltz. The singers were Bondar, whose Slavic accent was perfect for a role as vampire, and Roz White, a graduate of the Duke Ellington School of the Arts and a former student there of Janet Peachey's. The Dresser was particularly impressed with White's blues performance. Anderson expects that the playful vampire subject matter will make it more likely that this piece will go on to other performances.

3.  "Piano Bench" assignment:  The composers were asked to come prepared with two contrasting musical phrases.  For an extended time -- maybe 15 minutes, though I remember it as longer -- the composer was to play and replay those pieces for the librettist, not just serenading, but "noodling" around -- taking the chords apart, reconfiguring the phrases in various ways.  The librettist was to listen but not comment.  Later that day, the pair met again, heard the phrases again, and talked through various possibilities suggested by the music.  So, although the librettist wasn't setting words for the particular melodies, the trajectory for the project came from the music to the words, and then back to the music again.  Each team worked with one singer.

Pianist-cr

This assignment required the composer to come prepared with two contrasting musical phrases. Most song/aria writing starts with the words first which are then set to music. To the Steiny Road Poet’s ear, this assignment didn’t produce very memorable results, though she liked Anderson’s lyrics for “Blighted.” Anderson found the overall pieces more satisfying, particularly a song by another composer and librettist team which posed a lyrical pastoral theme with the driving rhythms of a contemporary subway ride. Greg Watkins, bass, the singer assigned to Anderson and her composer was another accomplished graduate of the Duke Ellington School of the Arts.

4.  Political assignment:  For this assignment, each team
worked with an ensemble -- either two singers or three.  One
of the singers in each group was assigned as the singers'
representative.  That singer and the librettist and composer were each asked to bring to the group a photograph representing something crucially important to them personally -- implicitly something political, though of course EVERYTHING is political.  The group's first task was to find a way of bringing all three photographs into some sort of synthesis.  We were asked (I'm half-quoting, half-summarizing here) to hone a one-sentence theme statement to serve as a spine for the narrative structure—all characters, events, and beats should be connected to and driven by this theme.

This assignment seemed complicated by the number of people involved and the requirement that a photo of personal importance from three different people be amalgamated into one overarching theme. However, in the opinions of Anderson and Steiny, the results produced satisfying performances of all five works. Possibly that was because, by the fourth assignment, the overall group of 15 had momentum from their  previous experiences. Anderson found that this assignment lent itself to compelling anthem-like pieces, particularly as writing for ensembles added voice to voice.

5.  Commissioning the Theater Song": For this assignment, each team was asked to create a version of the "32-bar AABA theater song" -- that is, following a formula telling a dramatic story in four quatrains.  We were asked to follow a regular structure -- perhaps some version of an Emily Dickinson hymn-based quatrain -- where the rhythm and rhyme patterns of the first two stanzas and the final stanza are identical, and the third stanza creates a structural contrast.  Examples included "Anything Goes ," "Somewhere Over the Rainbow," and "Send in the Clowns" -- none of which follow the required pattern exactly!  Composers were warned that scores "must be no more than three pages in length."  

But this assignment had a further component: each singer "commissioned" a song that they'd like to perform.  They were asked to identify a character, a setting, a situation, a mood, and a decision or event that changes things.  The teams interviewed or consulted with their singer for about a half an hour, and then each team also met with the organizers to report and reflect on their assignment.  

The results from the final assignment were a tour de force. Was it because of the formula, the accumulated experience bolstered by the two weeks in which composers, librettists, and singers had struggled together and deeply learned how to collaborate with each other, or some combination of these factors? The assignment encouraged the writing teams towards lyricism and wit, and the singers’ investment in the project made for particularly moving performances.

2025-ComposerLibrettists-cr

This program capped the third annual Composer-Librettist
Studio. Refer to the Alliance for New Music-Theatre website https://www.newmusictheatre.org in early January for information on how to apply for the next Composer-Librettist Studio. Hats off to the co-facilitators Susan Galbraith, who kept the three-hour program moving forward, and music director Sonja Thompson. Thompson was amazing in her ability to instantly adapt her piano accompaniment to each set of performances and appear not only ready but enthusiastic without a trace of fatigue.

inSight

 August 2025

 

Share This Page

View readers’ comments in Letters to the Editor

Karren Alenier is a poet and writer. She writes a monthly column and is a Senior Writer for Scene4. She is the author of The Steiny Road to Operadom: The Making of American Operas. Read her blog.
For more of her commentary and articles,
check the Archives.

 

©2025 Karren Alenier
©2025 Publication Scene4 Magazine

 

Writings
Index of Karren Alenier’s
columns in Scene4
Click Here for Access

 

  Sections Cover · This Issue · inFocus · inView · inSight · Perspectives · Special Issues
  Columns Adler · Alenier · Alpaugh · Bettencourt · Jones · Luce · Marcott · Walsh 
  Information Masthead · Your Support · Prior Issues · Submissions · Archives · Books
  Connections Contact Us · Comments · Subscribe · Advertising · Privacy · Terms · Letters

|  Search This Issue | Search Archives | Share Page |

Scene4 (ISSN 1932-3603), published monthly by Scene4 Magazine
of Arts and Culture. Copyright © 2000-2025 Aviar-Dka Ltd

 August 2025

Thai Airways at Scene4 Magazine
HollywoodRed-1